Food Guide In-Depth How To Guides

What’s a Good Substitute for Baker’s Ammonia?

bakers ammonia substitute
( Disclaimer: As an Amazon Associate, we earn commissions from qualifying purchases at NO additional cost to the customer.)                                          

Baker’s ammonia is also commonly known as ammonium bicarbonate and was used by bakers as the main leavening agent during the 19th century.

There are several Middle Eastern and European recipes of crackers and cookies that still use it.

So, what exactly is baker’s ammonia?

In simple terms, it is a substitute for the commonly sought-after baking powder and baking soda and is famous for the unique crispness and texture it imparts in baked items.

The important question that many of you will be wondering is, what can I use in place of baker’s ammonia?

You will be startled to know that there are quite a few baker’s ammonia substitutes that you can make use of.

You can substitute it with baking powder, cream of tartar, or baking soda and still bake your heart out.

So, without wasting time, let’s look at baker’s ammonia and its substitutes in detail:

What is Baker’s Ammonia?

Baker's Ammonia (Ammonium Carbonate Powder) (8 oz, ZIN: 528708)

Baker’s ammonia was primarily used before baking soda and baking powder made their debut.

Baking ammonia was initially made from a deer’s horns and was used as a leavening agent. This is why it was also referred to as ‘hartshorn’ because the term ‘hart’ is used for deer.

When baker’s ammonia is heated, it breaks down into three components, i.e., water, ammonia, and carbon dioxide.

This carbon dioxide is responsible for making the cookies and cakes rise.

As baker’s ammonia releases ammonia gas, it may affect the final product’s taste.

This is why it is used for cookies and other thin products from which the gas can easily escape. It isn’t used in cakes as they are moist and will retain most of the gas.

Baking ammonia is readily available at specialty food and drug stores and is bought in the form of a lump that has to be ground into a powder before using.

Always remember to store it in an airtight container.

Why Is Ammonia Used in Baking?

There are several reasons baker’s ammonia is a top favorite when baking.

What makes cooking ammonia unique is that it releases gas fast, which ultimately gives anything baking in the oven a speedy rise.

Unlike baking soda, it doesn’t require an acid or any other material to react with; moreover, it doesn’t even react with liquids as baking powder does. The most common advantages are:

  • The gases that are formed by the breakdown of the baker’s ammonia expand later on while baking.
  • It helps in modifying taste and flavor.
  • Baker’s ammonia helps to strengthen the dough.
  • The gases produced tend to expand the baked good’s walls, causing them to become more tender.
  • It works excellent in comparison to baking soda as it hardly affects the baked goods’ PH.
  • Not only does it make thin items like cookies crispy, but it also improves their texture.
  • Molded cookies tend to retain their shape and design well when cooking ammonia is used in the recipe.

How to Use Baker’s Ammonia?

Now that we have the basics sorted, the next important question is how do you actually use baker’s ammonia during your baking rendezvous.

Ammonium carbonate is most commonly mixed with a liquid before being mixed with the dry ingredients.

This allows it to blend smoothly and thoroughly.

Remember to store it properly as it quickly absorbs moisture and clumps up.

To check if it’s active, add a tiny amount to hot water. If it starts to bubble intensely, it’s good to go.

You can always substitute it with baking powder; however, the final product may differ in texture.

Rumford Baking Powder is a great option that can be used for any recipe whenever you feel like using baking powder instead of baker’s ammonia.

Bakers Ammonia Substitute

So, what do you do when the question running through your mind is, what can I use in place of baker’s ammonia?

The good news is that there are quite a few baker’s ammonia substitutes that you can use; let’s look at them in detail:

Baking soda

American Natural Baking Soda - TODICAMP® - Natural Sodium Bicarbonate Powder 8oz

If you can’t find baker’s ammonia, you can always use baking soda instead.

As baking ammonia is slightly stronger than baking soda, just add 25% more baking soda to the recipe.

This means that for one teaspoon of baker’s ammonia, you will need one ¼ teaspoon of baking soda.

Let’s look at some of the characteristics of baking soda:

  • It is an alkaline compound that combines with an acid to form carbon dioxide bubbles. When these bubbles get trapped, they make the batter or dough rise or expand.
  • As it decomposes, it also releases gas.
  • A temperature of more than 80 degrees Celsius in the oven causes baking soda to release bubbles.

It works as an excellent chemical leavening agent in several recipes, from bread to cakes to cookies.

Why not try this American Natural Baking Soda, which you can add to different beverages and foods.

Baking powder

Clabber Girl Baking Powder - 8.1 oz can (3)

Another excellent substitute is baking powder.

Not only is it inexpensive, but it also has a very long shelf life.

It is made up of three ingredients, a buffering agent, an acid, and a base.

All three are combined in specific proportions to form the baking powder we use.

If you don’t have baker’s ammonia at hand, simply use the same amount of baking powder.

  • It is used as a leavening agent in several baked goods.
  • When mixed with a liquid, baking powder undergoes an acid-base reaction that causes carbon dioxide gas to release into the dough or batter.

This reaction makes bubbles that make the wet mixture rise and expand.

The Clabber Girl Gluten-Free Baking Powder is an excellent leavening agent that is used for all kinds of delicious baking recipes.

It provides consistent results that you will fall in love with.

Cream of tartar

For starters, cream of tartar is definitely not creamy but is powdery and dry.

It goes by the scientific name potassium bitartrate or tartaric acid.

However, it can easily be found in any spice aisle with the name ‘cream of tartar.’

So, what makes it unique and the perfect substitute for baker’s ammonia?

Let’s find out:

  • When a small amount of cream of tartar is added while beating egg whites, it helps to stabilize the air bubbles.

This ensures that once you bake meringue cookies, they will have a melt in your mouth consistency.

  • When mixed with baking soda, it acts as a leavening agent by producing carbon dioxide.

Use a ¼ teaspoon baking soda with half a teaspoon of cream of tartar to substitute one teaspoon of baking powder.

Final Thoughts

Bakers ammonia has been around for decades and has helped several bakers achieve the perfect consistency and taste in their baked goodies.

Not only does it give cookies a nice crispy texture, but it also makes them lightweight.

So, what if you run out of baker’s ammonia?

You can always substitute it with baking powder, cream of tartar, or baking soda and enjoy your favorite recipes.


Related Articles:

Best Pan with Removable Bottom that Every Bakers Need!

Choco Bake Substitute

Do Nothing Bundt Cakes Need to be Refrigerated?