Food Guide

Hershey’s Syrup Can vs Hershey’s Syrup Bottle

Hershey's syrup can vs bottle
( Disclaimer: As an Amazon Associate, we earn commissions from qualifying purchases at NO additional cost to the customer.)                                          

Who doesn’t love Hershey’s chocolate syrup?

It is the ideal choice for any dessert.

From ice cream to waffles, anything can be covered and decorated with this syrup.

It is the favorite topping of all children and adults.

The low calorie in it makes you worry less about your health and more about your cravings.

The Hershey’s syrup comes in two different variations.

The syrup can and the syrup bottle. This puts us in a dilemma.

Which one would be the better choice? What is the difference?

This article has answers to all your questions. So, give it a read.

About Hershey’s Syrup Bottle

Hershey's Chocolate Syrup Bottle Quarter Module, 48-Ounce (Pack of 4)

The Hershey’s syrup bottle has a shape that makes it the best choice.

The bottle is made with plastic and has a squeezing design like no other.

The bottle has an upside-down design with an upside-down nozzle.

This nozzle makes up most of the difference.

Because of this nozzle, you can precisely design/ decorate your desserts with Hershey’s syrup.

When you squeeze the bottle, the syrup will come out of the narrow nozzle.

This eliminates the need for a spoon. The nozzle also prevents you from making a mess.

Moreover, the bottle design is child-friendly.

So, your children can freely decorate their ice cream and desserts without making such a big mess in the kitchen.

The Hershey’s bottle syrup design is slim, which can easily fit in your refrigerator with very little space.

It is true that the amount of syrup you will get in the bottle is less than the can, but so does the price.

You can buy more Hershey’s syrup bottles with the same money for buying only one Hershey’s syrup can.

So do not worry about the quantity.

All of the facts of Hershey’s bottle syrup make it the most convenient choice.

It also features the same chocolate syrup as the can, so there is no compromise in taste (Although people don’t agree on this fact).

About Hershey’s Syrup Can

The Hershey’s can comes in just like a shape of a cylindrical can with a round top opening.

From this shape, you can easily guess that it is not the best when it comes to decorating desserts with Hershey’s syrup.

You cannot directly pour the syrup from the can unless you want to make a mess.

You will need a spoon to take the syrup and pour it on desserts.

That is not the best way for decorating.

Some have come up with clever solutions like making a DIY piping bag and using that for decoration.

Either way, we can undoubtedly say that the can design is not perfect for decorating your desserts.

But still, the Hershey’s syrup can is as demandable as the Hershey’s syrup bottle.

The reason for it is a misconception made by the consumer.

Those who buy Hershey’s syrup can say that the canned syrup is made dense and thicker than the syrup in the bottle.

There is no such difference between the two.

The syrup of these two can be interchanged. That is the statement of Hershey.

Moreover, the cans have their problem of storing.

It takes up more space than the bottle.

Hershey also untied degradation of their chocolate syrup in the cans.

Difference Between Hershey’s Syrup Can and Bottle

The difference between Hershey’s syrup can and the Hershey’s bottle can is more than what you may think it is.

Not only the price and amount of syrup they hold are different but there is a difference in usability and functionality.

Amount of Syrup in Packaging

Usually, the amount of syrup is greater in the syrup can.

But there are big Hershey syrup plastic gallons.

If we take those in the count, then the amount of chocolate is greater in the plastic packaging.

Since we are focusing on the upside-down plastic bottle, the syrup can is the winner in terms of the amount of syrup in the can.


The price of the syrup can is higher than the price of the syrup bottle.

It is understandable. Because the amount of chocolate syrup in the can is way too much than the amount in the plastic can.

With the price of the syrup can, you can buy about three or more Hershey syrup plastic bottles.


In case of usability, syrup plastic bottles are the winner.

One of the key reasons why plastic bottles are high in demand is how you use them.

These bottles have a narrow nozzle on their opening, which is perfect for precise decorating on your desserts.

Moreover, the nozzle eliminates the need for a spoon.

It also prevents you from making a big mess with syrup.

The squeeze design of the battle allows you to control the flow of the syrup through the nozzle.

On the other hand, the only way you can use the syrup can for decorating is to use a spoon (ends up very messy) or to use a piping bag.

Either way, it’s not a good choice when it comes to decoration.

So clearly the Hershey Chocolate Syrup bottle is the best choice.


When it comes to storing, the plastic bottle takes little to no space in comparison with the syrup can.

The syrup can is a round cylindrical can with a considerable circular radius.

You may have some trouble storing it in the refrigerator.

But if you don’t store it in the refrigerator, the syrup will deform in the can (faster than the plastic bottle).

On the other hand, the Hershey syrup plastic bottle has a slim design.

This will allow you to place it in small places, which is very convenient for refrigerators.

So clearly, the plastic bottle wins in the storage factor.


When you consider all the factors, you can easily find that the Hershey’s syrup plastic bottle is the most convenient choice.

The syrup can take more place for storing and there are fewer decoration options.

But the plastic bottle has a nozzle on its opening and the squeezing design allows you to control the flow of syrup coming out of the nozzle.

Explore Our Here Best Melting Chocolate For Molds 

Hershey’s Syrup Can Discontinued

Unfortunately, Hershey does not manufacture syrup in cans anymore.

They now package their syrups in plastic bottles which are easily squeezable and have more interesting features.

The Hershey’s syrup can was discontinued in 1979.

The reason why Hershey discontinued the syrup cans is that the syrup will deform inside the can after a period.

That period is less than the time it would take the syrup to deform in plastic packages.

Besides, the plastic packages had more functionality than just being a package.

All of these factors made Hershey discontinue their stainless-steel cans and package all goods in plastic bottles.

Different Uses of Hershey’s Syrup

A touch of HERSHEY’S Syrup can make your regular desserts, snacks, and even breakfast to the next level.

You can mix Hershey’s chocolate syrup with chocolate milk. This loves the kids chocolate milk with Hershey’s chocolate syrup dressing.

You can combine ice cream with Hershey’s chocolate syrup. Whether you like plain vanilla or double-fudge rocky road, HERSHEY’S Syrup goes well with any flavor.

You can also try Hershey’s syrup on pancakes. I know you’ll never go back to your old maple syrup.

You can use Hershey’s syrup fruit dipping which is the fun way to enjoy the divine pairing of chocolate and fruit.

You can try it on sliced apples, bananas, grapes, and kiwifruit and make a quick but delicious snack.

How Long Does Hershey’s Syrup Last?

The shelf life of chocolate syrup depends on different factors like the best before date, the ingredients, and how the chocolate syrup is stored.

Hershey’s Chocolate syrup is made of corn syrup, cocoa, and water which have very long shelf lives.

The chocolate syrup lasts for a shorter period of time if it is not stored precisely.

If your Hershey’s syrup is sealed and unopened it lasts for 2 to 3 years in stored in the pantry.

If the Hershey’s syrup is opened and refrigerated, it lasts for 1 to 2 years.

Does Hershey’s Chocolate Syrup Go Bad?

Generally, Chocolate syrup lasts a long time, even after the date printed on the package.

That means that your bottle of Hershey’s chocolate syrup the week after the date on the label is almost certainly fine.

Though, chocolate syrup, like other toppings such as caramel or strawberry syrups, lowers in quality over a period of time.

The process is slow and takes a lot of time, that is months and years for the store-bought variety like Hershey’s.

If the question grapple in your mind that, does my Hershey’s chocolate syrup go bad?

Then I can tell that Hershey’s chocolate syrup can spoil quickly if it is not stored properly.

How to Store Chocolate Syrup To Extends Its Shelf Life?

The chocolate syrup should be always stored in a cool dark place like the pantry till it is opened.

Once it is opened it must be refrigerated.

Always store chocolate syrup in a tightly closed container to prevent moisture and other contaminants.

If bacteria enter into the container, then the chocolate syrup will spoil faster.

Don’t wipe the spout with a dishcloth or rinse the lid with water as this leads to allow contaminants to enter the chocolate syrup container.

Frequently Asked Questions

 Should Hershey’s syrup be refrigerated?

Hershey’s chocolate syrup recommends that “refrigerate after opening”. So, yes, Hershey’s syrup should be refrigerated.

Does Hershey’s strawberry syrup expire?

Yes, Hershey’s strawberry syrup comes with expiry date. As strawberry syrups contain corn syrup, sugars, perhaps some stabilizers, colours, flavours and water. They will be the waterloo which creates a quality defect that requires an expiry date.

Stabilizers used in syrup may not be able to hold on to the desired consistency after expiration date. The flavors of syrup will lose potency and may not taste as strawberry on its past expiration compared to fresh.

Final Thoughts

So, by all means, the Hershey syrup plastic bottle is the best choice in case of decoration, storage.

It prevents you from making a big kitchen mess.

But some may say that the syrup can have better chocolate than the syrup bottle.

They may confuse it with a different syrup can that was available for commercial use, not for consumer use.

The Hershey’s syrup can and the syrup bottle has the same ingredient.

Yes, by all means, the syrup bottle is the best choice.


Source Links:,in%2024%2Dounce%20plastic%20bottles.


Related Articles:

Does Wilton Candy Melts Expire?

Almond Bark Substitute

Choco Bake Substitutes